There’s something quintessentially New England about a lobster roll. Whether served chilled with a touch of mayo or warm and buttery, this iconic dish is the crown jewel of Cape Cod cuisine. But which is better? Cold or hot? Let’s dive into the delicious debate and explore the best places to indulge in each style on Cape Cod.
The Cold Lobster Roll: Classic and Refreshing
A cold lobster roll is a timeless favorite, offering a refreshing combination of fresh lobster meat lightly tossed in mayonnaise, often accompanied by a sprinkle of celery, chives, or lemon juice. It’s simple, unpretentious, and lets the sweet flavor of the lobster shine.
- What Makes It Special:
- A creamy texture that perfectly balances the lobster’s sweetness.
- Typically served on a lightly toasted and buttered New England-style roll.
- A go-to choice for hot summer days.
- Cape Cod Recommendations:
- Sesuit Harbor Café (Dennis): This waterfront gem serves one of the most famous cold lobster rolls on the Cape, piled high with fresh lobster meat.
- Arnold’s Lobster & Clam Bar (Eastham): Known for generous portions and perfectly toasted rolls.
- The Raw Bar (Mashpee): Home to an oversized lobster roll that’s both delicious and shareable.
The Hot Lobster Roll: Rich and Indulgent
A hot lobster roll, also known as “Connecticut-style,” takes indulgence to a new level. Instead of mayo, the lobster is bathed in warm, melted butter and served in a toasty, golden roll. It’s rich, comforting, and perfect for cooler days or those seeking a luxurious treat.
- What Makes It Special:
- The richness of the butter enhances the lobster’s natural flavor.
- A warm, satisfying alternative to the chilled classic.
- Perfect for lobster purists who want simplicity done right.
- Cape Cod Recommendations:
- The Lobster Pot (Provincetown): A must-visit spot offering a warm and buttery lobster roll with stunning harbor views.
- Moby Dick’s (Wellfleet): Known for its fresh and flavorful hot rolls served with a side of Cape Cod charm.
- Mac’s Shack (Wellfleet): A slightly upscale twist on the hot lobster roll, paired with an elegant dining atmosphere.
Which One Should You Choose?
The beauty of lobster rolls lies in their versatility. Here’s how to decide:
- Cold Lobster Roll: Opt for this if you love creamy textures and a refreshing bite—ideal for a picnic or a sunny day by the beach.
- Hot Lobster Roll: Perfect if you crave something rich, buttery, and indulgent—great for a cool evening or a cozy indoor meal.
Can’t Decide? Have Both!
Why not taste test both styles and decide for yourself? Many Cape Cod eateries offer both versions, so you can experience the best of both worlds.
- The Skipper Chowder House (Yarmouth): Famous for offering both cold and hot lobster rolls, allowing diners to enjoy the ultimate lobster roll showdown.
- Chatham Pier Fish Market (Chatham): Pick your style and enjoy it with a view of fishing boats unloading their daily catch.
